Caffeine is a triple threat when it comes to targeting issues common around the eyes. First and foremost, caffeine constricts blood vessels in the skin, which can reduce swelling and puffiness almost instantly. That also leads to benefits over time. “By improving circulation, caffeine can help diminish the appearance of dark circles under the eyes,” says Dr. Arora. Finally, caffeine is an antioxidant, which means it “helps protect the skin from environmental stressors,” he says.
It also depends on your own skincare concerns, according to Dr. Mitchell. “When choosing a caffeine eye cream, it’s important to look for key ingredients that enhance its effectiveness. Look for ones with hydrating ingredients like hyaluronic acid or glycerin to keep the skin plump and smooth, preventing dryness and fine lines,” she says. If you have dark circles, opt for one that has vitamin C, vitamin E or antioxidants to help brighten the skin, or, if you notice loss of elasticity, eye bags and wrinkles around your eye area, you can opt for caffeine eye creams that also have peptides or retinol in them to help increase and maintain collagen production.